ABS-CBN-2 vs GMA-7 (Virtual Presence vs Hologram)

IT PINOYs might have been amazed with how the two major (warring!) networks brought the recent Philippine Automated National Elections yesterday with the use of “virtual presence” and “hologramtechnologies.

in the last days before the election, GMA-7 boasted of it’s expensive set and eventually surprised everyone with it’s hologram effect of reporting (it looked like a scene from star wars!). well, this wasn’t really new as CNN used the same technology in the 2008’s US election and was actually based on a chroma-key technology that’s been taken “to the Nth degree.”
chroma-key is a technique for mixing two images or frames together, in which a color from one image is removed (or made transparent), revealing another image behind it. this technology is commonly used for weather forecast broadcasts, wherein the presenter appears to be standing in front of a large map, but in the studio it is actually a large blue or green background.

ABS-CBN 2 on the other hand used a technology called “virtual presence.” Joel Lamdani, vice president of Orad Hi-Tech Systems Ltd., explained that virtual presence is a feature of an advanced technology called Augmented Reality (AR), which blurs the line between what’s real and what’s computer-generated by enhancing what we see, hear, feel and smell.
unlike GMA-7s hologram, which was taken from an adjacent room, ABS-CBN 2’s virtual presence was taken on a live field report, which was way kewler!!

ABS-CBN 2 also had a gigantic touch screen and a “war room” that looked like those we see in big hollywood movies like “Armageddon” and “Apollo 13.”

like how Comelec succeeded with automating our national elections,  these new innovations are definitely a treat for all IT PINOYs as finally we have these technologies on our local tv’s. thought there’s still more cleanup to do (compared with CNN’s hologram) nonetheless, kudos to both stations for bringing their news reports to the next level – world-class!!!

read more [abs-cbnnews.com]

126 Comments

  1. Anonymous

    Hoi mas advance ang abs-cbn kase as what was explained hindi na kailangan ng green background, eh sa gma kailangan pa ng green backgroung so laos ang gma

    Like

  2. Anonymous

    mas maganda ang ABSCBN .walng binatbat ang GMA7. mas maganda ang technology ng abscbn kesa gma7.halata nmn ipinatong lang ung pic.manloloko pala ang gma7.”FAKE”

    Like

  3. Anonymous

    SANA MAGHOHOLOGRAM MAN LANG ANG GMA, SANA PINALITAN MUNA NILA SI MIKE ENRIQUEZ NG MEDYO MAY DATING, SOBRANG SAKSAKAN NG PANGET. SUPER IRRITATING PA NG BOSES. GMA used and bragged about holograms “kono” and it's being used daw ng CNN. Di man lang na-google ng GMA na masyadong pinagpipyestahan ng US IT people na hindi talaga hologram yun ginamit nila sa 2008 elections? Nakakaawa ang GMA. Tapos, if hindi na nila kaya, they'll bank on the statement na sila ay walang kinikilingan,… blah blah blah… tahanan katotothanan? hahahaha pasaway… eh ano ang tawag jan? Akala nila puro OGOK ang mga pinoy. Sinabi kasi ng “malaysian” guy na yon na hologram nga daw, eh naniniwala kaagad sila. How poor. tapos, nagyabang pa sa kanilang iPAD “kono” (di kaya hiniram lang yon?). Ang masaklap, oto-oto pa si Mel Tiangco, hinihintay pa ang cue ng crew kung kelan pipindotin ang mapa sa Google? I've seen that TV na, HINDI naman yong touch screen…. panu xa makakapag “touch effect” nun?Nung di na kaya ang mga negatve feedback ng holograms, eh, they coined another term: “hologram effect” daw, eh klarong klaro sa sinasabi ng onggoy na yon (mike manyakis) na HOLOGRAM… hahahahaha VERY POOR, SOCIAL CLIMBER AND SUPER TRYING HARD NETWORK. Eto pa, Jessica Soho, super nakaka suka… alam nyo na kung bakit… hindi kasya sa “HOLOGRAM” at lalong binawalan na i “touch” ang sinasabing “touch screen”, kasi baka MASIRA, matataba ang mga daliri. BYE.

    Like

  4. Anonymous

    Ang maganda sa ABS-CBN, hindi sila nagpasikat ng kanilang mga high tech na mga gamit, without a doubt, kaya bilhin ng ABS ang GMA, mga TV sets pa kaya? Ang nkakaawa pakinggan sa GMA ay panay banggit “mahal” “pinagkagastosan”, “binili”… eh sa ABS, wla lang… they just wanted to bring the Philippines whats new in the world para naman di tayo estranged sa technology.Walang dating ang hologram sa broadcasting… It doesnt even make sense, sobrang DRY pa ng mga graphics ng GMA. Mag AMA at PLDT or SMART pa… wala pa rin… marami phone patches sa mga coverage kasi ang mga inatupag ang paglalagay lang pala ng mga GREEN cloth para maisagawa ang chroma keys at magyabang sa HOLOGRAM …. ponyeta… sa GMA to be truly competitive, wag manggaya sa sobrang lumang technology. Tell me what you'll do with your top of the line “FAKE HOLOGRAM EFFECT” ?Sampal sa mukha ng mga IT people sa Manila kung ganun man lang ka IGNORANTE ang pagkaka intindi ninyo sa mga ganyan.I'm IT guy my self but, before I share or recommend something, dapat alam ko muna kung ano ang sinasabi ko.

    Like

  5. Anonymous

    ang babaw ng mga pinoy… pati to pinagaawayan… sana magkaroon ng another big network para mahati ang mga die hard fans ng dalawang network na to

    Like

  6. Anonymous

    TV5 first used the TOUCH screen n LED in their AKSYON SA KASAYSAYAn then followed by GMA for their YOUSCOOP then by the ABS-CBn for the comments they get from SOCIAL NETWORK. We can say that GMA HOLOGRAM is FAKE but GMA is the first NETWORK in the country used that. Then when ABS saw it they also find ways to have it they used it on afternoon while GMA in morning. GMA has IPAD they used it for viewing comments tweets and messages from social networks. IN PARTIAL UNOFFICIAL TALLY GMA is the first party to release the partial and unofficial count from COMELEC. they have a special software made just from ELECTION RESULTS. THeir computer is connected to PPCRV(and we all know that PPCRV is the only watchdog that is accredited by COMELEC for this election). WHEN the results where received by GMA computer their software automatically tally the results. So they are faster to release result than comelec. On the other hand, ABSCBN results are from COMELEC so their results ar quite slow than GMA. s EXIT POLLS nmn tau TV5 has commisioned SWS Survey sponsored by PLDT-Smart to do the polls. while ABS commisioned PULSE Asia to do the polls in partnership with BAYAN Com. The BOTTOM LINE is so far the FIRST AUTOMATED EELECTION in our country is GENERALLY SUCCESFUL despite the troubles in SOUTHERN part of our country and COMELEC HOTSPOTs. IN THIS ELECTION voter's turn-out is 75% which is relevantly high than past elections. I CONGRATULATE COMELEC for a JOB WELL DONE.

    Like

  7. Anonymous

    IF THEY USE HOLOGRAM, A PERSON WHO IS LOCATED IN A REMOTE PLACE MUST APPEAR VISIBLY IN THE STUDIO.But BASED in MY OBSERVATION, it's not a true hologram, mR. mIKE e. was just pretending that he saw the reporter in the studio. They only talk about the technology over in a place, which while impressive, it just goes to show you how GMA and others can lie to people by not telling the whole truth.

    Like

  8. Anonymous

    y is abs-cbn making a very big deal out of this. is it because pagdating sa news reportage taob cla ng gma at di nla matake na pati sa teknology eh mapantayan cla. ung nagsalita na foreigner kgbi sa tvp is i think from europe wyl ung sa gma is from malaysia(not xur). nahurt cguro dahil umabot pa cla ng europe eh meron naman d2 sa asia at preho lang naman ang knalabasan. wat was important naman and pretty sure u will agree is the news that is being delivered regardless of how high-tech it was delivered…gosh…bitter…so bieber…ahahaha**********************************************************************************ahaha! natawa ako dito to be fair to you..news report ba kamo taob ang abs-cbn? I just noticed lang kasi sa mga GMA7 reporters when they are reporting, it's either walang buhay or exagerated.. walang katikas-tikas, hindi mafeel yung reality sa mga nirereport, not even complete yung information that they are trying to convey. Hindi malinis ang details, hindi ka man lang maattract na makinig, kakahaggard pakinggan..Samantalang sa abs-cbn, hindi pa sila nagsasalita, presence pa lang nila talagang hihintayin mo silang magsalita..yung dating na parang napaka init talaga ng balitang isheshare nila..buong-buo at malinaw ang mga boses, snappy ang dating, hindi yung parang nagmemorize lang ng irereport at sapilitang pinatayo sa harap ng camera para magbalita..Isa pa, obvious na Mr. Mike is just pretending na nakikita niya yung reporter sa mismong studio nila? Try niyo kaya panoorin at tingnan kung saan nakatingin sa Mike Enriquez, hindi lumelevel ni swak sa anggulo ng kausap niya..base sa video sa taas, sa 0:56 if you could noticed sa iba nakatingin si Mr. Severino even si Mr Mike Enriquez. The two were just pretending that they could see each other.

    Like

  9. Anonymous

    Mtagal na tayong niloloko ng GMA, akalain mo i-claim nila na 60 years na daw sila at ang kaunaunahang TV network sa pinas. Whereas nauna naman talaga ang ABSCBN. I admire ABSCBN for remaining humble at hindi katulad ng GMA na puro boast na lang ng kanilang mga achievements, like this hologram achu chu chu chu nabokya tuloy.

    Like

  10. Anonymous

    so funny ng gma bwahahahaha pinangangalandakang wala silang kasinungalingan eh napaka sinungalung naman pala hahaha!! pa hologram hologram chuva pa sila eh PEKE naman pala .. mas mukhang hologram pa yata si Agua sa agua bendita bwahahahaha!! at isa pang bwahahahaha!! nakakahiya kayo!! ano daw? walang kasinungalinga walang pinoprotektahan etc. etc. eh dapat may karugtong pa yan .. walang credibilidad! walang may naniniwala! walang kuwenta! walang wala talaga compared to channel 2! bwahahahaha!!!

    Like

  11. Anonymous

    mas maganda cguro kung huwag na nating palakihin ang issues ng GMA and ABS-CBN tungkol sa mga high-technology things na ginamit nila . dba? 🙂

    Like

  12. Anonymous

    mas maganda cguro kung huwag na nating palakihin ang issues ng GMA and ABS-CBN tungkol sa mga high-technology things na ginamit nila . dba? 🙂Bakit? Para next time sabihin na lang na may gundam sila sa studio para tumaas ang ratings nila? That's cheap!

    Like

  13. Anonymous

    y is abs-cbn making a very big deal out of this. is it because pagdating sa news reportage taob cla ng gma at di nla matake na pati sa teknology eh mapantayan cla. ung nagsalita na foreigner kgbi sa tvp is i think from europe wyl ung sa gma is from malaysia(not xur). nahurt cguro dahil umabot pa cla ng europe eh meron naman d2 sa asia at preho lang naman ang knalabasan. wat was important naman and pretty sure u will agree is the news that is being delivered regardless of how high-tech it was delivered…gosh…bitter…so bieber…ahahaha**********************************************************************************ahaha! natawa ako dito to be fair to you..news report ba kamo taob ang abs-cbn? I just noticed lang kasi sa mga GMA7 reporters when they are reporting, it's either walang buhay or exagerated.. walang katikas-tikas, hindi mafeel yung reality sa mga nirereport, not even complete yung information that they are trying to convey. Hindi malinis ang details, hindi ka man lang maattract na makinig, kakahaggard pakinggan..Samantalang sa abs-cbn, hindi pa sila nagsasalita, presence pa lang nila talagang hihintayin mo silang magsalita..yung dating na parang napaka init talaga ng balitang isheshare nila..buong-buo at malinaw ang mga boses, snappy ang dating, hindi yung parang nagmemorize lang ng irereport at sapilitang pinatayo sa harap ng camera para magbalita..Isa pa, obvious na Mr. Mike is just pretending na nakikita niya yung reporter sa mismong studio nila? Try niyo kaya panoorin at tingnan kung saan nakatingin sa Mike Enriquez, hindi lumelevel ni swak sa anggulo ng kausap niya..base sa video sa taas, sa 0:56 if you could noticed sa iba nakatingin si Mr. Severino even si Mr Mike Enriquez. The two were just pretending that they could see each other.***********************************************************************************Apparently some people don't mind being dooped.. Maybe that's the problem with us Filipinos.. Masyado tayong walang pakialam.. Halata nang nandadaya, pinagtatanggol o kinukunsinti natin. Minsan kahit umamin na at nagbitiw na ng “I am sorry” patay malisya lang. At least yung GMA na yun nagsorry sa panloloko. Although wala siyang choice natakot na siya sa people power kaya para humupa ng konti tensyon.Haha anyways watch this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mTXF3W9L11s

    Like

  14. Anonymous

    GMA pa efek!!!! FAKE NAMAN..end of storyyun nah…nakita nyo ba c mel tianco na kunwari nag “touchscreen2x” para xang tangga…hahahaha

    Like

  15. Anonymous

    There no such thing of lies and fake. The use of terms only is the mistake. The term Hologram Technology should not be used but the term Hologram Effect. Hologram Technology as yet to be discovered to be used in live television streaming. CNN also has been criticized because of the claiming of Hologram Technology duirng their coverage of 2008 US elections. VIZRT made graphics both for CNN and GMA7. But as i said, only terminology used is the mistake and their is no such thing as lies and fake as bitter rival station is claiming

    Like

  16. Anonymous

    There no such thing of lies and fake. The use of terms only is the mistake. The term Hologram Technology should not be used but the term Hologram Effect. Hologram Technology as yet to be discovered to be used in live television streaming. CNN also has been criticized because of the claiming of Hologram Technology duirng their coverage of 2008 US elections. VIZRT made graphics both for CNN and GMA7. But as i said, only terminology used is the mistake and their is no such thing as lies and fake as bitter rival station is claiming***********************************************************************************If as you say that there was just a misunderstanding and the terminologies were just mixed up then please clarify these statements:1. There no such thing of lies and fake. The use of terms only is the mistake.2. CNN also has been criticized because of the claiming of Hologram Technology duirng their coverage of 2008 US elections.3. VIZRT made graphics both for CNN and GMA7.Because it apparently became a blur to me because as you said, 1. CNN commisioned VIZRT to do the so-called hologram. 2. CNN calls it hologram. 3. CNN gets heavily criticized. 4. GMA also hires VIZRT. 5. GMA also calls it hologram. 6. GMA says its a new technology. 7. GMA urges people to even wave their hands.8. GMA gets heavily criticized.So, did I get the wrong message about hologram and waving hands? Because as far as I'm concerned stating it on national television and the waving of hands is kind of implying it as the genuine hologram and not just hologram effect. Plus, if CNN and GMA both hired VIZRT, and CNN gets heavily criticized for it, then GMA must have known that it is in fact just hologram effect from the very beginning. Why still call it just hologram and even urge Noy to wave his hands… Plus yes the Mel Tiangco thing was hilarious!Don't get me wrong I don't hate GMA, I actually love their documentaries, which has depth and heart put in them. But something like this doesn't need protecting. So, I therefore conclude that its either I, and some others, are total fools and needs to go back to grade school and learn the proper meaning of words then get a masteral and doctoral in language, or we are just plain hippocrites.

    Like

  17. Anonymous

    First I congratulate ABS-CBN for an admiring, well planned, accurate and high technologically oriented election coverage last May 10 2010. C'mon guys… Let us all admit, Philippines is one the countries to adapt technology in late. But the mere fact that the 2 networks introduce that “kind” was a great job for both! But the main issue is that, “what was the reality behind virtual presence versus hologram that ABS-CBN and GMA used?” People must understand why IT people or non IT people criticized or even corrected GMA for the terminology since they are trying to give people the “precise information” which exist do today.It's not bad to debate such things and it's not even being “mababaw” as Filipinos to discussed this kind of issue because this is a big thing! And it's such ashamed if we got being reported by people from other countries for disinformation with regard to the terminology. This one is a very good example for boastful guys, and hope people will learn that before sharing information to others especially in public, please rest assured and have it surely confirmed by not just one IT person but as many as you can to get it accurately. Use world wide web, searched for it and then understand…Expand your knowledge…Okay GMA?

    Like

  18. Anonymous

    tingnan nyo nalang, ung virtual presence ng abs kita ung reporter pati na rin ung background, what i mean is ung nasa surrounding nya. eh sa gma ung mismong reporter lang ang andun. pagkumparahin nyo

    Like

  19. Anonymous

    tingnan nyo nalang, ung virtual presence ng abs kita ung reporter pati na rin ung background, what i mean is ung nasa surrounding nya. eh sa gma ung mismong reporter lang ang andun. pagkumparahin nyo********************************************************************************whats your point? na mas maganda yung ginawa nila kaso nababalot ng kasinungalingan o disinformation? merong smoke effect yung output nung hologram effect nila kasi hindi gaya ng cnn na 30+ cameras ginamit, sila isang camera lang ginamit. ang masama pa imbes na humingi ng pasensya patay malisya lang sila. binago lang yung term. nakihabol pa sa touch screen halatang peke naman. yung sa abs minadali lang pro katotohanan naman.

    Like

  20. Anonymous

    congratulations to kapamilya..I hate mike.arikis..lols..kakahiya xa mgbalita walang ethics ata un..umuubo pa..d man lang takpan muna ung bibig bago umubo..kakahiya xa tlga..excuse me poh..ulol..kala ko expresion lang un..un pala totoo pla tlga..bsta his sooo irritating..ang angas pa ampotek..duwag naman..magaling pa sa knya c anthony taberna..bilid ako dun..mtapang un..GMA ang aangas nu..halos araw2 sa balita nu my nadidinig akong no.1 kau lagi,nanalo kau sa gni2 gnyan..pwee..uo kau na no.1..no.1 sa kayabangan..LOLS..GO ABS….

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s